Lacey’s birthday party is ruined when her deepest fear reveals itself. But then it turns out everyone in town has their own unique fears. Everyone that is except Wanda. So Brent and Hank make it their mission to figure out what freaks her out. Meanwhile, Oscar tries to prove to Emma that he can cook which unexpectedly leads to illicit meetings with Karen. And Hank and Lacey both prove to be pretty bad liars.
Davis has a Battlestar Galactica theory that everyone on Earth could be the descendants of the last surviving Battlestar. Incredibly, five years after this episode aired, the re-imagined Battlestar Galactica series concluded with this exact twist.